Take a Fantastical Journey with “Big Fish” at Pentacle Theatre

Big Fish is about the bonds that define us: the stories we tell, the truths we share (and those we keep hidden), and the legacies we leave behind. Set against the backdrop of a fantastical narrative, the musical moves between two timelines. The present-day narrative follows an elderly Edward, who faces the reality of his own mortality, while his son, Will, navigates the upcoming arrival of his own child. Meanwhile, the past unfolds as Edward recounts his larger-than-life adventures, meeting a witch, a giant, a mermaid, and, of course, the love of his life, Sandra. As Will seeks the truth about his father’s mythical past, he uncovers a secret that challenges his entire perception of their relationship.

“This production is a beautiful story of relationships—father and son, husband and wife, friends, first loves, and even enemies,” said director Jill Sorensen. “I was introduced to the musical by a very close friend over a year ago and I fell in love with the storybook aspect of the production. I felt it would be perfect for the Pentacle stage.”

More than 50 people auditioned for the show, which made casting both exciting and challenging.

“We made the decision to split the lead characters of Edward and Sandra, with Noah Miller and Jeff Witt playing Young Edward and Mature Edward respectively and Natalie Pate Gwin and Heather Toller playing Young Sandra and Mature Sandra respectively,” said Jill. “Each actor has approached the role with thoughtfulness, energy, and commitment to each other. They have even learned each other’s music and blocking.”

“All of the actors will be very busy in the production,” said Jill. ”The incredible ensemble, which also includes named characters, are on stage throughout the show in multiple roles.

And what would a musical be without dancing?

“We have amazing dance numbers, choreographed by Dee Montgomery and Mat Genuser, that audiences will love,” said Jill.

Of course, any adaptation of a beloved film comes with its challenges. Big Fish is based on the 2003 movie directed by Tim Burton, and while the storyline has been altered for the stage, the essence of the film remains, said Jill. “As a theater, there are limits to what we can do on stage and that may leave some fans of the movie wanting—that reality can be challenging to reconcile. I think we have done a really good job producing a show that represents the movie well and stands on its own creatively.”

Overall, working on the production has been an “absolute pleasure,” said Jill. “My favorite thing about directing is watching the actors evolve into their characters—to see how much they care about doing their best and about giving the audience a fantastic experience. It is humbling to feel the love and respect that the cast develops for one another over a short period of time. Life long friendships are formed here. I have formed my closest friendships here. It is a privilege to witness.”

The magic doesn’t stop at the acting. The production will feature live music performed on stage, led by Music and Vocal Director Jon Stuber, further immersing the audience into the world of Big Fish.

The show runs from March 21 through April 12, with a special Children’s Educational Theatre Benefit performance April 2 and captioned performances on March 28 and April 5 at Pentacle Theatre, 324 52nd Ave NW.

Tickets are available now and are sure to sell quickly, so don’t miss out on this must-see production of Big Fish, an unforgettable tale of love, family, and the stories that make us who we are.

For tickets and more information, visit Pentacle Theatre’s box office at 197 Liberty St SE or call 503-485-4300. Tickets are also available online here.

This story originally ran in Press Play Salem issue 23 ( Spring 2025)